Understanding the Differences & Similarities between Wicca & Witchcraft
- “wicca” A wizard, soothsayer, sorcerer, magician. A male practitioner of magic Pronounced wee-cha (Old English noun)
- “wicce” A witch or sorceress. A female practitioner of magic. Pronounced wee-chay (Old English noun)
- “wicche” A witch or sorceress. (Middle English noun)
- “Wikken“ to use witchcraft or to predict (Low German verb)
- “Wicken” to use witchcraft or to predict (Low German verb)
- “Weik” having to do with magic or religion (Indo-European) This word is possibly the originator of the others.
To summarize what those words meant, and now mean:
Wicca (historical term) – referred to sorcerers, diviners and soothsayers, and was subsequently translated as “witch.”
Wicca (modern term) – an adherent to the modernized religion of Wicca.
Witch (historical term) – a practitioner of magic and or divination.
Witch (modern term) – can refer to both 1. an adherent of modern Wicca or 2. a practitioner of magic or divination by someone of any religion.
Witchcraft (historical term) – the practice of magic or divination.
Witchcraft (modern term) – can refer to both 1. The practice of magic or divination or 2. The practice of (modern) Wicca.
The terms “witch” and “witchcraft” are derived from words historically used to describe any practitioner of magic and or divination. Although these practitioners likely had a religious practice they ascribed to, the terms did not describe adherents to a particular religion. The modern term of “Wicca” is derived from the teachings of Gerald Gardner in the 1950’s. He used the word “Wica” (later changed to “Wicca,” the first evidence of which is in 1969) to refer to adherents of his particular tradition of witchcraft. Although I should note, he did not use the word at all in his first book. The religion that sprung from his teachings was then named Wica/Wicca. His teachings are thought to be based on a combination of an established witchcraft tradition, supplemented by additions by himself, Crowley and the Golden Dawn. But his story, and the debate surrounding his claims, are beyond the scope of this topic.
In summary, the terms “witch” and “wiccan” are not synonymous, nor are the terms “witchcraft” and “Wicca.” There are non-Wiccan witches and there are practitioners of witchcraft that do not practice Wicca. What makes it more confusing is that practitioners of Wicca call their religion the “Craft” or “witchcraft,” so those that have not fully researched the subject may assume that all witches are Wiccan and that witchcraft refers to religion. To further confuse the issue, many notable authors (including Raymond Buckland and Doreen Valiente) took Gardner’s lead in failing to differentiate the practices.
And as if all that was not confusing enough, what happens when someone calls themselves Wiccan, Wicca, or Wicce, using the original meaning (in Old English) of a practitioner of magic, and they are not part of the religion of Wicca?
Don’t get me wrong, I am not saying I am for or against the modern religion of Wicca. I am just saying that when early Wiccans adopted general terms to define their specific practice, they caused infinite confusion. And the only way I personally see the confusion being cleared, is if non-Wiccan (modern term) witches coin a new term for themselves. Not unlike the way the term “magick” was brought back in place of “magic” to differentiate it from illusionary magic. Which seems rather unfair since the general terms to describe a witch predate the modern dual definition by quite a bit, at least according to the evidence. But, such is the continued abuse of the English language.
So the next time someone tells you they are a witch, you may want to clarify by asking what religion (if any) they are.
~Anyanka
P.S. Might I add that this is a very good example of why it is a poor idea to reuse words. Especially when they have meanings that relate to each other in part, but are not synonyms.
I’ve done my best to separate the Wicca books from the witchcraft books in my store, but there will always be some overlap 
Related posts:
- 13 Preambles of Wicca by H.P. Thomas Moore
- Differences Between the Pentacle and the Pentagram
- Witchcraft Ethics & the Law of Karma
- Understanding a Mercury Retrograde
- Is it Magick or Magic?
5 Comments on Understanding the Differences & Similarities between Wicca & Witchcraft
Leave a comment
DandyID
Amazon
Amazon Wish List
Blip.fm
Blogger
CafePress
Digg
Ebay
Facebook Pages
Flickr
LibraryThing
MySpace
Squidoo
Twitter
Technorati
Yahoo! Answers
Yahoo! Profiles
43 People
12seconds
30 Boxes
BlogCatalog
Twello
Google Profiles
I was wondering whether you would be interested in contributing to the Witches Digest?
We are always on the lookout for people and groups who want to express themselves, and contribute to the Pagan Community – we need poetry, letters, artwork, articles, interviews, recipes, stories and personal experiences – to be featured in our magazine The Witches Digest.
Contributions are unpaid, as this is about the love of giving back to the pagan community, not the money.
You will receive a complimentary PDF copy of the issue in which your work appears, and where applicable we will include a full credit and a short write-up on the author for all content included in the magazine.
The topic is your choice, write (or create) what you are passionate about – whether it’s something you love or hate, a cause, an experience, a company or service… please take a look at our website to see what other articles have been written and to get a feel about what people are interested in.
http://www.witchesdigest.co.uk
I’d love for you to be involved as I think our readers would really benefit from your experience.
All the best, Dawn
I would be honored Dawn
Give me a couple weeks to get the new blog thing underway, and I will get right on that. Blessings to you and yours!
~Sandy
A big thank you. I am a Witch, and I am not Wiccan. I consider it more of a spirituality than a religiong; for me, Wicca is another form of organized religion, with lots of rules and liturgies. I am a Wild Witch, also called a Grey Witch. I feel a lot of Wiccans ignore the shadow self, and, without it, we ignore the balance. I don’t hex people, put spells on them…unless they ask me for one specifically for THEM…or anything like that. But, nature is a balance of light and dark; if youy ignore the dark, you can never fully appreciate the light.
Bright Blessings to you, and thanks!
An excellent point Manx! I too believe there is a place for “grey magick,” for the same reasons as you. To me it isn’t about an exclusion of the dark, but finding the harmony that can be found by recognizing it. All things in our life, good/bad, light/dark, serve a purpose. If one can harness their own dark energies, they can make their light all the brighter! I have a growing list of topics I want to write about, and this will definitely be one of them.
~Sandy
Hello,
I have just discovered this website and i’m happy i did!
I hope to share my creations and ideas for everyone to enjoy and give feedback.
Best wishes,
Alan